Monday, February 17, 2014

The Medical Industrial Complex is Driving Costs and Overtreatment

"Hey doc, I saw on an ad on the TV last night about this new asthma inhaler.  Shouldn't I give it a try?"  This type of question would occur several times a week.  When I started practicing medicine it was considered unethical to advertise medical treatments.  Now, we're bombarded with enticements for tests and treatments.  The inhaler the patient requested cost $264 a month - more than double what he was currently paying for an effective generic inhaler.

Somehow, we have brought into the hype that more is better, and that if you would just get your mammogram or PSA, that early detection would prevent cancer deaths down the line.  A recent study in the British Medical Journal found that the death rate comparing mammography with annual breast exams was no different.  And a significant number mammography patients went though additional surgery, radiation therapy, or chemotherapy - which was unnecessary.  The effectiveness of PSA monitoring remains controversial, and many prostates are being removed where the negative effects far outweigh a theoretical possible benefit.

The evening news ads bombard us with "low T" warnings and erectile dysfunction treatment promotions.  Somehow, testosterone experimentation is happening, much like the era of  hormonal replacement for all menopausal women.  The warnings of these drugs like blindness, rising PSA, or stroke are gently spoken while watching loving couples swimming or smooching.

A friend is now monitoring her glucose daily, even though she is barely pre-diabetic.  Somehow, she feels the need to be constantly monitored for the condition she does not (yet) have.

A 90 years old wants his cholesterol checked.  He'd like a drug for it that he saw on TV.  Really?

Most of now have a medically attended birth and medically attended death.  We now have the benefit of effective medications for blood pressure, diabetes, and abnormal lipid panels.  But the medical industrial complex wants us to be major consumers - more visits, more tests, more surgeries.  There is some evidence that may be making the industry nervous as health cost increases seem to have leveled a bit.

The industry to struggling a bit to bring out new blockbuster billion dollar drugs.  The dollars that go into the health care system are coming from our pockets and insurance premiums.  Given the waste and inefficiencies in health care delivery, this hurts the entire economy and has allowed the medical-industrial complex to become bloated.  Obviously a balance is needed.

There is bloat in duplication and overuse of high tech equipment.  The fastest way to pay off a new scanner is to run more tests.  The incentives are to do more in the fee for service system.  Pharmacy and device sales reps abound in doctors offices and hospitals.  Ethical lines are blurred when free meals and paid lectures are offered to MD's by the industry.  TV and magazine ads drive up cost and utilization.  Administrators want a lucrative bottom line.

Interestingly, we seem to be at a break point in terms of medical costs.  More is being shifted to patients as companies offer only HSA plans and often high deductibles.  More doctors are becoming salaried.  Malpractice settlements have peaked and appear to be declining with subsequent savings in malpractice premiums.  More efficiencies appear to be evolving.  The congressional budget office has reduced its estimates of Medicare spending by 12% (109 billion) by 2020.

My concern is the that medical industrial complex will become even more aggressive.  The possibilities will be more ads, direct mailings, "free" screenings, discounted surgeries, false claims of testing and treatments, etc.

My advice:  be a careful and cautious consumer.  Don't become medicalized.  And to the medical profession:  be more proactive countering the barrage of biased information we hear and see daily.


  1. Thank you, I've recently been searching for info
    approximately this subject for a while and yours
    is the greatest I've discovered till now. But, what about the conclusion?
    Are you certain in regards to the source?

    my web page

  2. Economic predictions are always uncertain, but medical costs in the USA far exceed those of any other developed nation. There is waste and duplication in the system. The industry continues to negatively impact the non-health care corporations. Policy is having some impact, but true cost containment would require laws and controls that are unlikely to pass. But I think the cost curve will continue to be gently bent down as we find a way to pay for health care by other incentives that don't encourage overuse.

  3. Hey,This kind of question would happen a few times each week. When I began polishing solution it was viewed as untrustworthy to publicize medical medications. Now, we're barraged with temptations for tests and medicines. The inhaler the patient asked for expense $264 a month — more than twofold what he was presently paying for a compelling nonexclusive inhale.Thank you so much!!
    cfr part 820

  4. Hey,The film joins the stories of patients and specialists caught in the framework with experiences by thought-pioneers, for example, Dr. Donald Berwick, Administrator of the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS), Dr. James Weinstein of Dartmouth and bio-ethicist Dr. Larry Churchill of Vanderbilt. Cash Driven Medicine goes past wellbeing protection change as it lays out the approaching strategy challenges for the one decade from now in the event that we are to give all Americans successful, fantastic, patient-focused consideration while holding expenses and lessening inefficient, even unsafe methods.Thank you!!Sara Rodriguez.....

  5. Thanks for taking the time to discuss about this, I feel strongly about it and love learning more on this topic. If possible, would you mind updating your blog with more information? It is extremely helpful for me.
    MRI Scanner

  6. You definitely come with exceptional articles.